Buying Christmas presents for somebody who plays Magic: The Gathering should be incredibly easy.
After all, this is a person who voluntarily collects little pieces of cardboard.
How complicated could this possibly be?
Very.
The problem isn’t finding Magic stuff. There’s an absolutely ridiculous amount of it. The problem is figuring out what your Magic player actually wants without knowing what formats they play, what colors they run, which decks they’re building, or why a piece of cardboard that looks suspiciously similar to another piece of cardboard is somehow worth dramatically more money.
So I’m taking a different approach.
Instead of trying to guess which cards somebody wants, I went looking for Magic: The Gathering gifts that almost any regular player can actually use.
Sleeves. Deck boxes. Dice. Tokens. Storage. Playmats.
You know, all the crap required to protect and organize the other crap.
And because Christmas presents should occasionally be more exciting than organizational supplies, I’ve thrown something into the final spot that they can actually tear open.
Here are my top ten.
1. Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves, 100 Count
Best for: Every Magic player who has ever announced, “I’m not building another deck.”
Check Dragon Shield Matte Sleeves on Amazon
Let’s start with perhaps the safest Magic gift in existence.
Sleeves.
Magic players need sleeves.
Then they need more sleeves.
Then they build another deck and mysteriously need sleeves again.
I don’t completely understand how a household can contain thousands of card sleeves and simultaneously never have enough card sleeves, but Magic players have accomplished it.
Dragon Shield Matte sleeves are exactly the sort of gift I like for someone whose specific collection you don’t understand. You don’t need to know what cards they’re playing or what strategy they’re running. You’re simply giving them something to protect the expensive cardboard they already own.
And unlike buying actual cards, you’re considerably less likely to accidentally spark a forty-minute explanation about why the thing you bought won’t work in their deck.
Pick a color they’ll like and you’re halfway done with your Christmas shopping.
2. Ultimate Guard Sidewinder 100+ Deck Box
Best for: The player whose current deck transportation system involves a backpack and prayer
Check the Ultimate Guard Sidewinder 100+ on Amazon
Once you’ve sleeved all those cards, you’ll eventually discover another problem.
You have to put the damn things somewhere.
A good deck box isn’t necessarily the most exciting Christmas present in the world, but it’s one of those things a regular player can appreciate every time they head out for a game.
And there’s something nice about upgrading somebody from whatever battered container they’ve been carrying around for the last several years.
Magic collections have an interesting way of getting expensive without ever really announcing that they’ve become expensive.
One day you’re buying a couple of packs.
A while later you’re carrying a small fortune around in your backpack and thinking perhaps the old sandwich bag wasn’t the ideal storage solution.
That’s where a proper deck box starts making quite a bit of sense.
3. Gamegenic Tolarian Community College Academic 133+ XL Deck Box
Best for: The Magic player who takes deck storage very, very seriously
Check the Gamegenic Academic 133+ XL on Amazon
If the Sidewinder is a nice deck box, this is for somebody who has progressed to the point where their cards deserve accommodations.
And honestly, that’s how Magic goes.
First you need somewhere to put your cards.
Then you need a nicer place to put your cards.
Then your deck box has compartments.
Then your compartments need accessories.
Eventually you’re less a card player and more the curator of a traveling cardboard museum.
The Gamegenic Tolarian Community College Academic 133+ XL makes sense as the more substantial deck-box gift on this list. If the person you’re shopping for plays regularly and already has a serious collection of accessories, this is the direction I’d look.
It also has the advantage of actually feeling like a Christmas present.
There’s absolutely nothing wrong with opening a pack of sleeves on Christmas morning.
But this is more substantial.
Consider it the difference between giving someone a new screwdriver and giving them a nice toolbox.
Both are useful.
One wraps better.
4. Gamegenic Playmat Tube
Best for: The person currently stuffing a nice playmat into a backpack like an animal
Check the Gamegenic Playmat Tube on Amazon
This is exactly the sort of accessory people neglect until they own a playmat they actually care about.
Then suddenly rolling the poor thing into a loose cylinder and throwing it into a backpack alongside a water bottle doesn’t seem like such a brilliant idea.
A playmat tube is wonderfully straightforward.
Playmat goes in.
Playmat gets protected.
Civilization advances another step.
This falls squarely into my favorite category of gifts: things people probably need but haven’t gotten around to buying for themselves.
It also makes a nice add-on if you’re buying somebody an actual playmat.
Which brings us conveniently to…
5. Ultra PRO Magic: The Gathering FINAL FANTASY Clive and Ifrit Double-Sided Playmat
Best for: The Magic player who also knows exactly who Clive and Ifrit are
Check the Ultra PRO Clive and Ifrit Playmat on Amazon
Now this feels more like Christmas.
A playmat is useful, but unlike a box or a tube, it also lets somebody put a little personality onto the table.
And the Clive and Ifrit design is especially fun for somebody whose Venn diagram of interests contains both Magic and FINAL FANTASY.
This is one choice on the list where I’d pay at least a little attention to the recipient.
If they love FINAL FANTASY, excellent.
If they’ve never played one in their life and can’t tell Clive from your cousin Steve, I’d probably choose another design.
But that’s also what makes a playmat a good gift.
It’s personal without requiring you to know exactly which cards somebody needs.
And paired with the Gamegenic tube above, you’ve got a pretty damn good two-part present.
One gives them the nice playmat.
The other stops them from destroying it.
6. Chessex Dice Set / Dice Block
Best for: The player who never has the right number of dice despite owning 400 dice
Check the Chessex Dice Set on Amazon
Magic requires dice.
Not necessarily because the basic premise of the game demands that you arrive carrying a small casino, but because eventually counters start appearing everywhere.
Then somebody needs another die.
And another.
And another.
Before long the tabletop looks like Las Vegas opened a branch office inside a comic-book store.
That’s why dice are such a safe little Magic gift.
Even if the person already has dice, congratulations.
Now they have more dice.
Problem solved.
That’s one of the great things about shopping for hobbies that consume small accessories. There’s usually no point where having another set becomes catastrophic.
And if there is, I’m pretty sure most Magic players passed it years ago.
7. Gamegenic Token Silo
Best for: The person whose dice and tokens currently live in nineteen different places
Check the Gamegenic Token Silo on Amazon
We’ve acquired dice.
We’ve acquired tokens.
We’ve acquired counters.
Now we need somewhere to put all of this nonsense.
Enter the Token Silo.
This is another accessory I particularly like as a Christmas gift because it’s solving an organizational problem rather than asking you to understand somebody’s deck.
If you’ve ever watched a tabletop game grind to a halt while everyone searches for a particular counter, marker or die, you’ll understand the appeal.
Or perhaps you’re the person doing the searching.
In which case, buy one for yourself and call it an early Christmas present.
I’m not judging.
Personally, any product that reduces the amount of time I spend saying, “I swear I had one of those right here,” deserves consideration.
8. Citadel Black Dry-Erase MTG Tokens, 50-Card Set
Best for: The player who needs a token for something nobody at the table expected to exist
Check the Citadel Black Dry-Erase MTG Token Set on Amazon
I really like this idea.
Sooner or later, Magic produces a situation where somebody needs a token nobody has.
Maybe it’s straightforward.
Maybe it’s something ridiculous.
Maybe your board state has reached the point where explaining exactly what’s happening requires a whiteboard, an accountant and several members of the United Nations.
Whatever the case, being able to make a temporary token solves the problem nicely.
This set gives you reusable dry-erase cards rather than requiring you to own every possible token you might ever need.
And I love gifts like this because they’re useful without being excessively specific.
You don’t need to know what deck your recipient plays.
You’re essentially handing them blank pieces and saying:
“Whatever bullshit your deck decides to create, write it on this.”
Beautiful.
9. Card Binder
Best for: Anyone whose collection organization system is currently “I know it’s around here somewhere.”
Check the Card Binder on Amazon
At some point, loose cards cease being a collection and begin becoming a geological layer.
You find one on the desk.
Three in a drawer.
A stack beside the computer.
Twenty in a box you don’t remember putting there.
And somewhere among all of them is the exact card you’re looking for.
Probably.
This is why a good card binder makes such an easy gift.
It’s useful for organization, protection and simply being able to look through part of a collection without excavating the spare bedroom.
This is another choice I’d especially consider for someone getting deeper into Magic.
They’re eventually going to need storage.
Lots of storage.
Because whatever number of cards they currently own is apparently not the correct number.
The correct number is always more.
10. Magic: The Gathering Nauctis: The Sunken Realm Bundle
Best for: The Magic player who deserves something they can actually rip open
Check the Nauctis: The Sunken Realm Bundle on Amazon
We’ve spent nine entries being responsible.
We’ve protected the cards.
We’ve organized the cards.
We’ve purchased boxes for the cards, sleeves for the cards and a binder for even more cards.
Enough responsibility.
Let’s open some damn Magic.
Nauctis: The Sunken Realm is an upcoming Magic release, making this the forward-looking selection on the list rather than another organizational accessory.
And that’s exactly why I wanted a product like this in the final slot.
Accessories make sensible gifts.
Opening Magic packs is fun.
You have no idea exactly what’s going to appear, and that’s the whole damn point.
If you’re shopping ahead for a Magic player who’s excited for the new set, this gives them something more substantial to look forward to than another package of sleeves.
After all, without new cards, what are they supposed to put in all the storage equipment you just bought them?
Don’t Know What Deck They Play? Be Careful Buying Individual Cards
There is one glaring omission from this Christmas list:
Individual Magic cards.
That’s intentional.
Specific cards can make fantastic gifts if you know exactly what the person wants.
If they’ve mentioned a particular card seventeen times, sent you the listing and drawn a small map showing where it can be purchased, you’re probably safe.
Otherwise?
I’d be careful.
Magic players don’t simply throw random cards into random decks based on whether the artwork looks cool.
Well, presumably somebody does.
But there’s a very good chance that blindly buying an individual card leads to you handing over your thoughtful present and hearing:
“Wow! Thanks!”
Followed internally by:
“What the hell am I going to do with this?”
If you know their wish list, individual cards can be fantastic.
If you don’t, buy accessories.
What I’d Buy
If I were shopping for somebody relatively new to Magic, I’d probably start with Dragon Shield sleeves, Chessex dice or a good binder.
They’re easy gifts to understand and useful as a collection grows.
For somebody who plays regularly, I’d look harder at the Ultimate Guard Sidewinder, Gamegenic Academic 133+ XL, Token Silo or dry-erase tokens.
For the person who’s already accumulated all the practical stuff and is also into FINAL FANTASY, I’d go with the Clive and Ifrit playmat.
And if I wanted something that simply feels fun to open?
I’d go with the Nauctis bundle, especially for someone already looking forward to the new set.
Because sometimes the correct Christmas present isn’t another thing for organizing your hobby.
Sometimes it’s more hobby.
The Best Magic Gift Doesn’t Have to Be a Card
That’s the takeaway here.
You don’t need to understand your recipient’s deck.
You don’t need to secretly photograph their collection.
And you certainly don’t need to spend the next three nights learning Magic deck-building just to determine whether the piece of cardboard you’re about to order is useful.
Look at the accessories surrounding the game instead.
Sleeves wear out.
Collections grow.
Decks multiply.
Dice disappear.
Playmats need protecting.
Cards inevitably require yet another box because the previous eight boxes have somehow become full.
These aren’t necessarily the flashiest gifts in the world, but they’re things Magic players actually use.
And if all else fails?
Buy them sleeves.
Someday they’ll build another deck.
They always build another deck.


