I made it this far.
For all these years, despite listening to plenty of classic rock, owning guitars, spending an unreasonable amount of time thinking about amplifiers, pedals, speakers, tone, and all the other things normal people successfully avoid thinking about, I had somehow never actually sat down and listened to Yoko Ono sing.
I knew about Yoko Ono.
Everybody knows about Yoko Ono.
She’s one of those figures you absorb through cultural osmosis. John Lennon loved her. Beatles fans have been arguing about her since roughly the invention of dirt. People have spent decades debating whether she was misunderstood, unfairly blamed, artistically brilliant, wildly experimental, or simply standing in a room where everybody desperately wished she were standing somewhere else.
But I had no opinion.
Then a Yoko Ono song came on.
And now I have an opinion.
Oh. So THAT’S What Everybody Was Talking About.
At first I thought something had gone wrong.
Not metaphorically. I genuinely thought there might be a problem with the recording.
Maybe the stream had glitched.
Maybe two audio tracks had accidentally been laid over each other.
Maybe somebody had left a microphone on in an adjacent studio while something unfortunate happened involving a cat.
Then I realized:
No.
This was the song.
This was intentional.
People recorded this.
Other people mixed it.
Presumably several adults were present throughout the process.
At some point someone listened to the final version and said, in effect, “Yep. Ship it.”
That may be the most astonishing part.
I’ve Heard Nails on a Chalkboard With Better Phrasing
Look, I understand experimental music.
At least I understand the idea of experimental music.
Artists are supposed to push boundaries. Music would be terribly boring if everybody just played a I-IV-V progression through a Fender amplifier for the rest of human history.
Experimentation gave us enormous leaps forward in recording, guitar effects, electronic music, distortion, feedback, synthesizers, sampling and countless sounds that initially seemed insane.
But experimentation carries a risk.
Sometimes you push the boundary forward.
Sometimes you discover why the boundary was there.
My first Yoko Ono experience felt less like listening to somebody sing and more like witnessing a very confident argument against the concept of pitch.
I have heard smoke detectors with warmer tone.
I have heard vacuum cleaners sustain notes more gracefully.
I once heard a belt slipping on an automobile alternator that I would describe as considerably more melodic.
And Suddenly I Understand John Lennon’s Friends
For decades I assumed the stories surrounding Yoko Ono had been exaggerated by Beatles mythology.
Surely, I thought, people were piling on.
Surely history had turned a complicated collection of personalities and artistic disagreements into the overly convenient story of “Yoko showed up and everything went crazy.”
And to be clear, I’m still not blaming one person for the breakup of one of the biggest bands in history. Human beings, unfortunately, are more complicated than VH1 documentaries.
But after hearing her sing for the first time, I suddenly understand one very specific thing:
If I were sitting around with John Lennon and he said, “I want you guys to hear what Yoko has been working on,” there is a very real possibility that I would suddenly remember an urgent appointment in another country.
It would have nothing to do with relationships.
Nothing to do with art-world politics.
Nothing to do with jealousy.
I would simply need to leave.
Immediately.
Maybe I’m Just Not Sophisticated Enough
And that’s entirely possible.
Maybe somewhere there is a conservatory professor listening to this stuff through handcrafted headphones, nodding thoughtfully and appreciating layers of avant-garde expression that my primitive guitar-player brain cannot comprehend.
Good for him.
I hope he’s happy.
I’m over here trying to figure out whether my tweeters survived.
That may be the beauty of art. Two people can experience exactly the same thing and walk away with completely different interpretations.
One person hears fearless experimentation challenging traditional notions of vocal performance.
I hear a woman attacking a microphone while the microphone quietly regrets its career choices.
Neither of us necessarily has to be wrong.
Although I have a strong suspicion I am considerably more fun at parties.
The Verdict
So after spending most of my life having absolutely no firsthand opinion about Yoko Ono’s music, I finally understand the controversy.
Do I think she’s historically interesting?
Absolutely.
Do I understand that deliberately unconventional art isn’t fairly judged by the same standards as a Journey record?
Sure.
Do I want to listen to another song?
Absolutely not.
I have learned what I needed to learn.
There are musical experiences that make you want to grab your guitar.
There are musical experiences that make you want to turn up the volume.
And then there are musical experiences that make you stare silently at the speakers for several seconds before checking whether homeowners insurance covers psychological damage caused by Spotify.
Yoko Ono accomplished something remarkable today.
She made a middle-aged guitar player understand an argument people have been having since before he was born.
Rating: 1 confused Beatle out of 5
Recommended for: Avant-garde enthusiasts, experimental-art historians, and anyone who has ever wondered whether a smoke detector could front a band.
Would I listen again? I already did my part.

