Making a list
Product Comparisons: Figuring Out What’s Actually Worth Your Money
There are approximately eleven billion products for sale on the internet, and somehow every single one of them is “premium.”
Premium TVs. Premium vacuums. Premium monitors. Premium blenders. Premium guitar pedals. Premium dog bowls.
Apparently we have reached a point in human civilization where even the bowl your dog drinks out of requires extensive research.
That’s where these comparisons come in.
The goal here isn’t to find the most expensive product, the newest product, or whatever happens to have the longest feature list this week. We’re trying to figure out what we’d actually spend our own money on.
Because that’s a considerably different question.
How We Pick the Best Stuff
I look at products through a fairly simple lens:
Is this thing worth what they’re asking for it?
A $900 product doesn’t automatically beat a $500 one because somebody added RGB lighting and the word Pro to the box. Likewise, buying the cheapest thing available isn’t saving money if you’re replacing the damn thing six months later.
I care about the sweet spot.
Performance. Reliability. Features you’ll actually use. Build quality. Long-term ownership. And, most importantly, whether spending another couple hundred bucks actually gets you something worthwhile.
Sometimes it does.
Sometimes you’re buying a logo.
No, I Haven’t Personally Bought Every Product on These Lists
Let’s get this out of the way.
I have not personally purchased every television, monitor, vacuum cleaner, guitar pedal, kitchen appliance, and assorted technological contraption appearing in every Top 10 article on this site.
For one thing, that would be financially catastrophic.
When I haven’t personally owned or used a product, the recommendation is based on published specifications, reputable reviews, testing and research from other sources, owner feedback, pricing, and comparisons with competing products.
In other words, I do the homework.
But these lists aren’t assembled entirely from behind a computer screen, either.
I tend to buy quality stuff and then use it until either it dies or somebody invents something substantially better. That means there’s usually at least one product, or something closely related to it, that I actually own or have spent real time using.
That firsthand experience gives me a useful measuring stick for the rest.
If I know firsthand what a good monitor looks like, what a powerful vacuum feels like, or what a decent guitar pedal sounds like, I have a much better idea of what matters when comparing the alternatives.
And when something has been personally owned or tested, I’ll tell you.
Price Matters Around Here
There’s a peculiar strain of product review that always seems to end with:
“The $2,499 model is the best.”
Well, you’d certainly hope so.
The more interesting question is whether it’s $1,500 better than the $999 model.
That’s the question I care about.
I’m looking for the point where spending more money stops producing meaningful improvements and starts producing better marketing materials.
Sometimes the expensive option really is worth it. Other times the middle-of-the-road model gives you 95 percent of the experience and leaves enough money in your bank account to buy groceries.
I’m particularly fond of those.
What Makes Our Top 10 Lists
There’s no magic formula involving seventeen spreadsheets and a laboratory full of people wearing white coats.
I look at the things I’d want to know before pulling out my own credit card:
- Performance: Does it actually do its primary job well?
- Price: Are you getting enough improvement to justify what it costs?
- Reliability: Is this likely to stick around for a while?
- Useful features: Not how many features it has, but how many anybody will actually use.
- Competition: Is there something better for the same money?
- Owner experience: Are real buyers seeing problems that aren’t obvious from the spec sheet?
- Long-term value: Will I still be happy I bought it a few years from now?
And finally:
Would I buy it myself?
That’s the filter everything eventually has to pass through.
Research Matters. So Does Actually Owning Stuff.
I think there’s value in both.
Professional testing can measure things the average buyer can’t. Specifications can reveal important differences between products. Long-term owner reports can expose problems that don’t appear during the first week of a review.
But there’s also something valuable about living with products.
You discover that the button everybody praised is irritating. The software everybody complained about really isn’t that bad. The appliance you thought you’d use twice a week gets used twice a day.
That’s why these comparisons use both approaches whenever possible: published research when necessary and firsthand experience when available.
Not pretending otherwise seems like a reasonably good policy.
Find the Best Crap for Your Money
Below you’ll find our growing collection of Top 10 lists and product comparisons covering the stuff we actually find interesting enough to argue about.
TVs & Displays
Monitors, 4K displays, televisions, and all the enormous glowing rectangles we’re apparently incapable of living without.
Pedals, amps, accessories, power supplies, and other devices musicians buy while insisting they’re finally finished buying gear.
Vacuums, carpet cleaners, washers, dryers, and all the machines we’ve invented because scrubbing things by hand is for our ancestors.
The appliances and gadgets competing for the approximately four square feet of counter space that remains in your kitchen.
Consoles, electronics, accessories, and whatever else somebody has managed to attach a processor to.
Things your dog absolutely needs, according to the company selling them.
More comparisons will be added as we research, buy, break, repair, replace, and occasionally discover products good enough that we won’t shut up about them.
The Bottom Line
These aren’t lists designed to convince you that the most expensive product is automatically the best.
They’re designed to answer a much more useful question:
If it were my money sitting on the table, which one would I buy?
Sometimes that’s the flagship model.
Sometimes it’s the ugly one sitting halfway down the price range quietly doing everything you actually need.
And occasionally the smartest purchase is keeping what you’ve already got.
If we can help you tell the difference, we’ve done our job.
Joe Zimmerman
Joseph Zimmerman is a lifelong tinkerer, traveler, and professional asker of “is this thing actually worth the money?” He writes honest reviews, Colorado adventures, and assorted nonsense at ShouldIBuyThisCrap.com

